5-0 5 ayes, 0 nays, roll call at 0:38:46Motion to approve 'with the conditions that we talk[ed]' (0:38:36); mover and seconder not named. Roll call from 'Vice Chair Gonzalez?' (2326.9 s): Gonzalez, Stamato, Kaplan, Patel, Langston each 'Aye' (p 1.00); 'Motion passes' (0:38:58). Gangadin was not called: a member said 'Chair, I'd have to recuse myself on this one' as the item was read (0:03:00, speaker not named) and the chair noted 'Commissioner Ganga[din] is back' at 0:40:19. RESO P2025-0086 (decided and memorialized March 10, 2026) prints 'Vote: 5 - 0' with Yes marks for Langston, Gonzalez, Patel and Kaplan only, Gangadin under Recusal, Wick and Stamato Absent; Desai not listed. tools/resolutions.py read Gangadin's mark as a nay; the PDF text puts it in the Recusal column. See needs_checking (Stamato). The resolution (RESO P2025-0086) prints 'Vote: 5 - 0' but marks Commissioner Stamato absent and only four members yes; Stamato is heard 'Aye' (0:38:51). Published as heard on Adam Hanford's review of 2026-10-20.
4-0-1 4 ayes, 0 nays, 1 abstention, roll call at 3:27:09One roll call on 5 resolutions (item 31), split per resolution on Adam Hanford's decision of 2026-10-20: 'Gangadin not-voting on P2025-0086'. Gangadin answered aye but did not vote at the hearing (planning-2026-03-10, item 8) and is not-voting (rule A); Gangadin, recused at the hearing (item 8), answered aye and is not-voting on Adam Hanford's decision. RESO P2025-0086 (https://jerseycitynj-energovpub.tylerhost.net/apps/selfservice#/plan/ecb2a781-84a9-4c75-88bc-0991fce5ba57?tab=attachments) gives decision and memorialization March 10, 2026; its vote table is item 8's hearing roll call, not this one. Kaplan said 'I'll abstain on these' as not present at the earlier hearings (3:27:14); the announced count was 'Five in favor, one abstention' (3:27:20). Roll call as heard: One roll call on five resolutions. Motion read from 3:24:22 (mover not clearly named: 'Mr. Stamato. Both Stamatos.'), seconded at 12424.3 s. Roll call from 'Vice Chair, Dr. Gonzalez?' (12429.8 s): Gonzalez, Gangadin, Stamato 'Aye'; Kaplan 'Is it appropriate for me to abstain on this item since I wasn't here ... I'll abstain on these' (3:27:14); Patel 'Aye' (12441.9 s, p 1.00) and Langston 'Aye' (12443.1 s). Patel's separate answer rests on the re-transcription of 12415-12461 s; the full pass ran 'Commissioner Patel and Chairman Langston. Aye.' together. Announced 'Five in favor, one abstention' (3:27:20) agrees. Held on eligibility: Gangadin answered aye on a roll call that included the resolution for P2025-0086, on which Gangadin was recused (item 8); see needs_checking.