Denial: preliminary and final major site plan amendment with ‘c’ variances, Michael and Claudia Case, 87 Bright Street, Block 13905, Lot 12

Item 31.1 · memorialization · Memorialized · 5:33:49

One roll call memorialized the seven resolutions read from 5:33:49 to 5:36:39 (items 31.1 to 31.7). No motion is heard; a second is heard at 5:36:44, speakers not named. The secretary's roll call began at 5:36:47; Commissioner Barnaby, called twice, answered 'I'm sorry, aye.' (5:37:03), and every other member answered aye. 'Motion carries all in favor to memorialize resolutions.' (5:37:28); no count announced. The resolution memorialized, RESO P2024-0088 (resolution of denial; decided June 30, 2026), prints the June 30 hearing's vote, not this one. Whether every member was eligible to vote on this case was not checked against the June 30 hearing. Published on Adam Hanford's decision of 2026-10-18.

Item 20.3 · memorialization · Memorialized · 3:54:58

The reader said the denial resolution must be re-memorialized because 'Councilwoman Little was recused from the action' and should not have voted to memorialize it; Little was not present (3:55:30 to 3:55:45). Motion: 'I will approve the memorialization of the stated application.' (3:55:55), speaker not named; no second heard. Roll call 'On a motion to approve' from 'Commissioner Barnaby.' (3:56:05, word timing): Barnaby 'Aye.' (3:56:06) at p 0.34 in the full pass and p 0.02 in the re-transcription without VAD of 3:56:01 to 3:56:12, below 0.5 in both: not-voting. Kaplan asked whether it was 'a motion to deny' and was told 'It is a motion to memorialize the denying resolution', then 'Aye.' (3:56:19, p 1.00). Conaway, called three times, 'Aye. I was still on mute. Aye.' (3:56:33 to 3:56:35, p 0.92 and 1.00). Patel, Capers, Stamato, Wick 'Aye.' (p 1.00); Gangadin 'Aye.' (3:56:52, p 0.97). Little absent. Heard: 7 ayes (tally as heard). 'Okay, motion carries.' (3:56:54). No count announced. Memorialized: RESO P2024-0088 on EnerGov (https://jerseycitynj-energovpub.tylerhost.net/apps/selfservice#/plan/6006273b-4003-4fd4-81a2-7ca3925bfa30?tab=attachments), copies added 2026-08-19 marked 'Re-Memorialized: August 11, 2026' (p. 1, p. 22; text in _live/planning-2026-07-28.resolutions/). Eligibility (only members who voted for the action at the hearing may memorialize): its vote page (p. 22) lists Patel voting against the denial at the June 30, 2026 hearing; Capers, Conaway, Barnaby, Kaplan, Stamato, Wick and Gangadin in favor. Reading as heard (recorded): Patel aye, 7-0. Reading under the eligibility rule: Patel not-voting, 6-0. Adam is deciding how eligibility applies when an ineligible member answers; see needs_checking (20.3). Barnaby: answer as read by Adam Hanford on the video, or from the clerk's announced count where the audio is silent ('8-0. Barnaby is aye'). Published on Adam Hanford's decision of 2026-10-18.